Distinctiveness and dominance: what really sways the INPI

In many oppositions, the earlier and the contested signs share the same word. The whole debate then turns on the “value” of that word: a taking of the sign for the opponent (supporting a likelihood of confusion), a commonplace term free for all to use for the applicant (arguing for the opposition to be rejected).

The Sabel judgment provides the method: assess the overall impression produced by the signs, taking account of their distinctive and dominant components.

But how does the INPI actually qualify these components? And do those qualifications really tip the decision?

Glossaire

Glossary

  • INPI opposition: proceedings allowing the owner of an earlier trademark to oppose the registration of a later application, within two months of its publication.
  • Global assessment: the method for analysing conflicting signs, derived from EU case law, which requires reasoning on the overall impression produced by the signs, taking account of their distinctive and dominant components.
  • Distinctive character: the capacity of a component to identify the commercial origin of the goods or services concerned. A component may be distinctive, weakly distinctive, or devoid of distinctive character (customary, generic, purely laudatory).
  • Dominant component: a component which, by its position, size or distinctive power, shapes the overall impression produced by the sign.
  • Infringement found: the conclusion by which the INPI holds that the contested sign imitates the earlier mark to the point of creating a likelihood of confusion.

We analysed the 1,000 most frequent word components in INPI opposition decisions, representing more than 45,000 occurrences, and the way the INPI qualifies each of them. We then matched these qualifications against the outcome of nearly 4,400 comparisons of signs sharing the same words.

Here is what the data shows, and what it changes for your practice and your clients.

Finding no. 1: when the INPI rules, it most often finds the component “weak”

When the INPI assesses the distinctive character of a word component, it finds it distinctive in only 44% of cases. In 38% of cases, it qualifies it as weakly distinctive, and in 18% as devoid of distinctive character. More than one time in two, the component under review is therefore considered weakly distinctive.

How the INPI qualifies word components: 44% distinctive, 38% weak, 18% non-distinctive
Chart 1: How the INPI qualifies word components

Conversely, some components are almost never discussed. The French articles DE, LA and LE each appear in 800 to 1,000 decisions, yet their distinctive character is examined in only 2 to 4% of them: they are “neutral” by default.

Components found weakly distinctive or non-distinctive fall into three clear families:

  • Geographical and terroir terms: PARIS (97% weak or non-distinctive findings), FRANCE (98%), CHATEAU (98%), DOMAINE (97%), CHAMPAGNE (98%).
  • Generic business terms: SERVICES, GROUP, GROUPE, INTERNATIONAL, CONSULTING, FINANCE, IMMOBILIER, found weak in 100% of cases, and CONSEIL in 99%.
  • Positioning or format terms: BIO (99%), .COM (99%), PRO (98%), MAISON (97%), COLLECTION (98%).

At the other end of the spectrum, ZARA, EDEN, ESPRIT, PASSEPORT, NEXT or PLANETE are found weak in only 0 to 14% of cases. What they have in common: a semantic content unrelated to the goods and services concerned.

Finding no. 2: distinctiveness is assessed in relation to the goods or services, not the word itself

EASY illustrates the point better than any other component. It is found distinctive in 52% of cases and weak in 48%. This split is no inconsistency. For software or services presented as easy to use, the term is laudatory and part of everyday vocabulary; for other goods, it becomes a fanciful term again.

PLANETE follows the opposite path. Present in classes 35, 41, 38 and 16, it is still found distinctive in 86% of cases, because it evokes none of those services.

Distribution of the word components CANAL, CITY, EASY, ELITE, ESPRIT, PARIS and PLANETE across Nice classes
Chart 2: Word components that matter by Nice class

A word therefore has no distinctiveness in itself. It has distinctiveness for given goods or services, and that is the level at which the analysis must be carried out.

Finding no. 3: a weakly distinctive or non-distinctive component is almost never dominant

Distinctiveness and dominance go hand in hand. Across the 170 most frequently qualified components, the correlation between weakness and lack of dominance reaches 0.75 (Spearman coefficient, where 1 would mean a perfect match).

The weaker a component, the less it is found dominant: 86% dominance for the most distinctive quarter, 25% for the weakest
Chart 3: The weaker a component, the less dominant it is

The INPI's reasoning shows through: when it finds a component weak, it most often infers that this component cannot dominate the overall impression or be the one remembered by the public, and shifts the analysis to the rest of the sign.

Dominance nonetheless remains relative to the sign itself. CITY is found distinctive in 83% of cases, yet non-dominant in 34%: in “X CITY”, another, stronger component often takes centre stage.

Finding no. 4: dominance weighs more heavily than distinctiveness on the outcome

When two marks share the same word, the way the INPI usually qualifies that word is reflected in the outcome.

Shared wordInfringement found
Most distinctive quarter of words83%
Weakest quarter of words64%
Quarter of words most often found dominant92%
Quarter of words most often found non-dominant64%

Dominance opens a 28-point gap, distinctiveness a 19-point gap. The correlations confirm it: 0.77 with dominance, 0.53 with distinctiveness.

Crossing the two qualifications is even more telling. A distinctive and dominant word leads to infringement being found in 84% of cases. A distinctive word that is often found non-dominant does so in only 68% of cases, almost as low as a weak and non-dominant word (64%).

Infringement found: 84% if the shared word is distinctive and dominant, 68% if distinctive but non-dominant, 64% if weak and non-dominant
Chart 4: Infringement found by the usual qualification of the shared word

Concrete examples draw the same line. Sharing PARIS or .COM leads to infringement being found in 50% of cases, MAISON in 58%, CITY in 59%. Sharing PASSEPORT does so in 100% of cases, EDEN in 98%, BOSS in 97%, PLANETE in 87%.

Rate of infringement found when two marks share PASSEPORT, EDEN, BOSS, PHOENIX, PLANETE, CITY, MAISON, PARIS or .COM
Chart 5: Infringement found when two marks share the word

Distinctiveness is a precondition; dominance is what turns it into a likelihood of confusion.

What this changes in practice

  1. Before filing: avoid building a mark on a geographical, terroir or generic term, and choose a component that is arbitrary in relation to the goods concerned. Then give it pride of place in the sign: a strong component relegated to the background loses most of its protection.
  2. When opposing: do not merely show that the component taken is distinctive. You must establish that it dominates the overall impression, in the earlier mark as in the contested sign.
  3. When responding to an opposition: challenge the qualification of the shared component for the goods at issue. If it is weak for those goods, it cannot be dominant, and the analysis shifts to the components that set the signs apart.

This is exactly what lipstip enables: retrieving in seconds how the INPI has qualified a given component, for given goods, with the source decisions to back it up. Where a manual search would take hours, you get a statistical overview and the relevant precedents, ready to cite.

Request a lipstip demo

Methodology: analysis of the 1,000 most frequent word components in opposition decisions published by the INPI, and of the qualifications retained in the reasoning (distinctive, weakly distinctive, customary or descriptive, non-distinctive; dominant, secondary or weakly dominant, non-dominant). A single component may be qualified several times within one decision. The link with the outcome covers comparisons of signs sharing the same word, for the 105 components with sufficient volumes, i.e. 4,396 comparisons. It establishes a trend, not a decision-by-decision causal relationship. Correlations measured with Spearman's coefficient.

The essentials in 30 seconds. When the INPI qualifies a word component, it finds it weak more than one time in two: geographical and terroir terms, generic business terms, positioning terms. This weakness depends on the goods concerned, not on the word: EASY is found distinctive one time in two, weak the other. A weak component is almost never dominant, and dominance is what weighs most on the outcome: infringement is found in 92% of cases where the shared word is usually dominant, and in 64% where it is not.

Join the Thread

Join lipstip's newsletter and stay ahead of the european IP transformation. News, features, exclusive content and opportunities : subscribe and do not miss a crumb.